Tuesday, July 7, 2020

Focus the Blame on the Virus

Dr Ada M Fisher

Misplaced Blame
To open or not to open, that is the question.  Food, clothing and shelter are major markers in Maslow’s hierarchy of needs considered essential services.  But in a pandemic -- health care availability, public safety and emergency services aren’t far behind.  Whether businesses or schools should be considered of such importance is a debate entered by those who fail to understand human as well as world dynamics. 
Reopening schools is a most important dynamic which should be a prime consideration for our children are suffering from pandemic enforced isolation and have become most vulnerable to violence, intellectual poverty without critical resources, diminished physical activity and many more problems. So too are their parents or guardians who are in imposed imprisonment under the same self-quarantine under the guise of social distancing.  Of prime concern should be an understanding that these are they who are our future, but by the same token, they must be prepared to engage in a world of uncertainty not made easier by leaders unprepared to lead and media driven Me Too Mania.
As Dr. Anthony Fauci, one of the nation’s premier infectious disease authorities is sadly acknowledging, the corona virus is unlike any other and so much is unknown.  It is fallacy to assume the world should be put on lock down until a vaccine is found or immunity can be proven.  Such is not likely to happen in the foreseeable future while the reality is government cannot support people financially indefinitely.  Hundreds of health care specialist have petitioned the World Health Organization to acknowledge that the corona virus is air borne.  Such a finding is devastating for it’s an admission that there is no hiding place from its reach or devastation.  Regular mask as an expectation are not a guarantee of protection but they are the best hope for limiting the spread of the disease as well as its possible secondary causes.
Government enforced compliance with health directives can be imposed under the Police Powers Acts granted in years past; however, such flies in the face of the US Constitution and Bill of Rights which guarantees individuals rights of assembly, freedom of religion and various other individual mandates which cannot be squashed by national concerns.  That will await constitutional court challenges.  Don’t blame the government when individuals exercise such rights.  We must have persuasive and credible leadership to meet these challenges using a Bully Pulpit to unite rather than divide.
So let’s talk schools.  Yesterday I sent my 8 year old grandson to the Esse Mae Fox Charter School’s Summer School developed in conjunction with parts of the Rowan Salisbury School System and he returned a different child.  He was happier, delighted to engage with his peers and had learned some fundamentals of response to the pandemic.  They got to choose their face mask which made compliance with their use tolerable, made sanitizer and played games which captured their imaginations as well as love of the weird and gross outs.  Children need the stimulation gained from interaction with their peers and as the American Academy of Pediatrics has acknowledged, there is no substitute for this.  Children need to get out of the house and explore their environment.  That’s how they grow.  That self actualization is at the top of Maslow’s pyramid of needs.
All of this may indeed place them at risk to their health; but isolation may equally stunt their growth.  One of my favorite medical school professors, Dr. June Osborn (She headed the US Task Force on AIDS) in teaching about vaccinations told me she would rather expose her kids to a live case of Chicken Pox than wait for a vaccine.  Having survived Scarlet Fever, Red Measles (Rubeola),  German Measles (Rubella), Meningitis (Viral), exposure to TB, meningococcal meningitis, Shingles (a form of chicken pox) and who knows what else from front line service to my fellow humans, one appreciates  that all life has certain risk from which one cannot be isolated.
Understand that despite all that human kind has been exposed to in the annals of human disease; the corona virus is unlike anything ever seen.  It seems almost alien.  It is theorized that there is a Swine Flu/1918 Flu like virus which could be worse already in animals in China -- will it be actualized?  There is no guarantee of anything and though one may wish to second guess what is, the real question posits there is no hiding place from facing reality and understanding that we need to get on with life not sequestered in a fear of what ifs, but using the best advice out there.  It’s time to Keep On Keeping On and Get On With Life.
Ada M. Fisher, MD, MPH is a former Medical Director in a Fortune 500 company, licensed teacher, retired physician, former county school board member, speaker, author of Common Sense Conservative Prescriptions Good for What Ails Us Book 1 (available through Amazon. Com) and is the NC Republican National Committeewoman.